88%Brazilian Shuffle

Laranja Reserva Hybrid Toro

September 30, 2026

Cigar Reviews, $10 to $15 Range, 2026

Erik Espinosa has never been one to let a good name gather dust. The Laranja Reserva first showed up in 2014, built around a striking orange-hued Brazilian wrapper, and it quickly racked up 90-plus scores and a... Read More...

88%Peppered Lumber

Saint Luis Rey Eiroa 30th Anniversary Toro

Scott Braband

September 23, 2026

Cigar Reviews, $10 to $15 Range, 2026

Saint Luis Rey is one of those brands that has managed to survive long enough to become part of cigar history, while somehow avoiding the spotlight enjoyed by some of its competitors. While the Cuban version da... Read More...

85%Paper Tiger

Undercrown El Tigre Dominicano Toro

Eric Guttormson

September 16, 2026

Cigar Reviews, $10 to $15 Range, 2026

I must admit, I was a bit surprised when Drew Estate announced that the next Undercrown would be a Dominican-themed cigar. After all, the brand has been closely tied to Nicaragua since its debut in 2011, when t... Read More...

91%Bond Villain

LFD Carbon Flower

Rob Rasmussen

September 2, 2026

Cigar Reviews, $15 & Over, 2026

When I think of La Flor Dominicana cigars, I think of power. The Double Ligero and the Andalusian Bull were some of the strongest cigars to hit the market at the time of their release. I even remember the Color... Read More...

90%Amar Well Earned

Amar by AJ Fernandez Torito

Scott Braband

August 20, 2026

Cigar Reviews, $10 to $15 Range, 2026

In an industry where new releases often focus on celebrating milestones or showcasing rare tobaccos, the Amar by AJ Fernandez takes a more personal approach. Introduced during the 2026 PCA Trade Show, the cigar... Read More...

86%Mellow Middle Ground

Sarzedas Toro

Scott Braband

May 13, 2026

Cigar Reviews, $8 to $10 Range, 2026

Sarzedas isn’t some new blend trying to feel old, it actually is old. The name dates all the way back to 1900, when J.C. Newman first introduced it during the early days of American cigar manufacturing. Back th... Read More...

91%Intentional Evolution

La Aurora Family Creed Fuerte Sol Toro

Scott Braband

February 11, 2026

Cigar Reviews, $15 & Over, 2026

La Aurora is a legacy brand known for consistency, with a portfolio that has long followed a recognizable profile and approach. Because of that, any move away from that identity naturally draws attention. Fuert... Read More...

86%Do Disturb?

Alec Bradley Do Not Disturb (DND) Toro

Chad Tchad

December 11, 2025

Cigar Reviews, $8 to $10 Range, 2025

Alec Bradley has always placed an emphasis on the atmosphere and mood created through their cigars. With their latest project, Do Not Disturb (or DND), they urge us to take a break, silence those phones, and en... Read More...

89%Bold & Spicy

Camacho Limited Edition 2025

Scott Braband

November 5, 2025

Cigar Reviews, $15 & Over, 2025

The Camacho Limited Edition 2025 marks a new chapter for the Camacho brand, replacing the long-running Liberty Series that had become a staple of Camacho’s annual lineup since its debut in 2002. While the Liber... Read More...

84%Spected More

Cohiba Spectre 2025

Scott Braband

October 29, 2025

Cigar Reviews, $15 & Over, 2025

Since its debut in 2018, the Cohiba Spectre series has stood at the very top of the ultra-premium cigar world, at least in terms of price and outlandish packaging. Each release has been a one-time, hand-tailore... Read More...

87%True Blue

My Father Blue Toro

Jordan Guttormson

October 22, 2025

Cigar Reviews, $10 to $15 Range, 2025

For most of the 21st century, the García family’s empire has been defined by one country: Nicaragua. What began as José “Pepín” García’s modest Miami-based workshop evolved into one of the largest vertically in... Read More...

85%Minor League

Punch Mr. Punch’s Wieners

Chad Tchad

September 25, 2025

Cigar Reviews, $5 to $8 Range, 2025

Punch is no stranger to Father’s Day hijinks in the form of their limited/annual cigars. This time, for 2025, they tied on the apron and fired up the grill for some Mr. Punch’s Wieners. Their past limited relea... Read More...

Tagged Toro