HVC is one of those brands that continues to impress me. The list of fantastic blends in their portfolio is longer than my… uh… well, we don’t need to get too specific—but it’s long. From the immensely flavorful 500 Years Anniversary, to the delicious Serie A, and the delightful Hot Cake, they never seem to let me down. So I was thrilled when I heard they were going to start experimenting with Broadleaf.

The First Selection Broadleaf first hit the market as a limited-edition release back in 2018. It was available in two sizes and limited to 500 boxes. It was so popular that they brought it back in 2019 and made it part of their regular production.

HVC First Selection Broadleaf Toro Breakdown

  • Wrapper: Connecticut Broadleaf
  • Binder: Nicaragua
  • Filler: Nicaragua
  • Factory: Aganorsa Leaf (Nicaragua)
  • Production: Regular Production
  • Vitola: 6″ × 52 (Toro)
  • Price: $11.50 (MSRP)
  • Atlantic Cigar Sale


The look is quite simple. The band is predominantly red, with gold embossing and white text. The secondary band shows the “industry classic” black with gold trim and “Broadleaf” in gold text. The Broadleaf wrapper has a dark, marbled look, with a slight oily sheen. It’s not flashy in the least. It’s almost humble.

Click images below for full resolution

Smoking Experience

The Broadleaf wrapper gives off a punch of aroma. Notes of black pepper, fresh soil, oak, mild molasses, and milk chocolate are very present. The cold draw tasted of stewed dark stone fruit (dark cherries, plums, etc.), whole peppercorn, and raisins.

The first puff hit me with a ton of flavor. It was like a churro covered in plum preserves and dipped in dark chocolate. Throw in a note of black pepper and a hot red pepper on the retro and you get an idea of what we’re working with here. The smoke was thick and the flavor was rich.

HVC First Selection Broadleaf Toro cigar smoking

The middle portion added in some dark, earthy notes, and the churro note became more of a ginger snap cookie. A roasted espresso note joined the show at the midpoint, and we were on our way.

The final third brought the churro back, and the black pepper picked up on the palate. The red pepper heat was still there on the retro, but it lost much of its potency. There was a lot going on in the final third of this beauty, but it maintained balance and was never harsh on the palate.

HVC First Selection Broadleaf Toro cigar ash

Would I Smoke This Cigar Again?

Of course. The only thing that will keep me from smoking this on the regular is the availability. I chalk its current hard-to-find-ness up to the pandemic. This is a regular-production cigar, and I imagine it will be easier to find in the coming months.

Additional Info
  • Originally released as an LE in 2018.
  • Became regular production release in 2019.
  • Available in a 4½” x 52 Short Robusto and 6″ x 52 Toro.
  • The rare blend out of the Aganorsa Leaf (TABSA) factory to use a Connecticut Broadleaf wrapper.

  • Flavor: Full
  • Strength: Medium-Plus
  • Body: Medium-Plus
Core Flavors
  • Stewed Dark Stone Fruit
  • Churros
  • Dark Chocolate
  • Black Pepper
  • Smoke Time: 1 hour, 40 minutes
  • Pairing Recommendation: Manhattan | Old Forester Rye | Black coffee | Dr. Pepper
  • Purchase Recommendation: Buy as many of these as your budget and storage space allow. I’m usually not a box buyer, but I will make an exception here. The next time I see a box of this beautiful Broadleaf available, I’m going to snatch it up.

HVC First Selection Broadleaf Toro cigar nub finished

HVC First Selection Broadleaf Toro
This is a beautiful expression of Broadleaf. It is a flavor journey. I’ve smoked a few since I took my notes for this review, and every time I felt like Frodo taking his first step out of the Shire. With that said, this is not an everyday smoke, in my opinion. However, when I want to go on a Broadleaf journey, I know I can fire up an HVC First Selection Broadleaf and I will not be disappointed.
  • Rich profile
  • Lots of transitions
  • Fun pairing opportunities
  • Becoming hard to find
91%Beautiful Broadleaf
  • Dunbarton Tobacco & Trust
Share This