At the 2015 IPCPR Trade Show this year, Acme Cigar Co. not only introduced three new cigars, but they also introduced themselves as a new company. Elliot Suied, owner of Cigar Warehouse in Dallas, and Romereo Hartfield, CEO of Millennium Multi-media Inc., partnered together to create their first cigar company. Tom Poehler and Jay Lundy of AKA Cigars have also teamed up with the two new Acme heads and together released their first line of cigars this year in New Orleans.

Acme Cigar Company started things off with a bang, releasing three top-of-the-line cigars with a range of vitolas to boot: The Acme Premier Ecuador, Acme Premier San Andres, and the Acme Route 66. I chose to go with the Route 66 because of its unique vitola and awesome rustic look.

Acme Route 66 Breakdown

  • Wrapper: Ecuadorian Cuban-seed Habano
  • Binder: Jalapa Criollo
  • Filler: Nicaraguan, San Andres and Dominican
  • Factory: Nicaraguan American Cigars S.A. (Estelí, Nicaragua)
  • Production: Regular release
  • Vitola: 8.5” x 52 Tandem
  • Price: $7

Acme Cigar Co. Route 66 cigar review

At first look, anyone will notice the sheer size of the Tandem vitola. It’s a monster. But looking beyond that, it has a very fine wrapper of a light to medium brown, very smooth with minimal veins and tight seams throughout. The wrapper doesn’t have an oily sheen or shine to it, but has more of a dry, rustic touch that, in my opinion, goes great with the band. The band, as you can imagine, sports a classic route 66 highway sign with the typical red and blue with white font. But Acme went one step further than that by adding touches of rust (literally) to the sign and blotches of dirt and grime. It all flows nicely together, creating a unique, rustic, slightly dirty cigar.

  • Atlantic Cigar Sale

You will also notice that the cigar has a nice double cap – not in the traditional sense of the term – it is actually capped on the head and foot. And not only that, but both caps have already been punched cut, so you can start smoking from either side right away, no cutter required. Furthermore, in the middle of the cigar, you will see a small, darker-colored tobacco band that marks the center of the cigar. This is so you don’t have to smoke the giant monster all at once, but is actually designed to be cut in the middle, giving you two 4.25” x 52 cigars already cut and ready to light!

Smoking Experience

For the review I chose not to cut the cigar, but to smoke all the way through. I wanted to do this so I could get the complete smoking experience and be able to note all the transitions and differences between each half of the stick.

On the cold draw there is a sweet tobacco and light oak coming through, but nothing substantial. On the first light and first few draws, there is a very nice cream that comes through, dominating the draw—on the finish you get more of that sweet tobacco core with a rather chewy smoke that gives you a nice, heavy mouthfeel. The draw is a bit tight at this point, not uncomfortable, but enough to require more effort than I would like to give. As the cigar slowly moves through the first third, it develops a nice pepper on the finish, as well as the retrohale. At this point, the cream is almost completely gone, leaving a plain black pepper and slight sweetness on the finish. The finish grows longer and longer as the smoke develops. The ash doesn’t like to hold on more than an inch and a half, so be mindful of that.

Acme Cigar Co. Route 66 Cigar Review

About an hour in, I approach the halfway point, and this is where the first transition happens. Right about the exact halfway mark, those notes of cream and subtle oak come right back to my palate, almost exactly like the first light. The pepper remains, but is dialed back by the cream and chewy smoke that comes ramping back to my mouth. But as I move an inch or so down past the halfway mark, those creamy and chewy oak notes begin to die back down again, just like in the first third. The transitions are nice and subtle, never harsh or out of place. It’s nice to know that Acme created two very similar halves to this stick so that you really do get the same subtle transitions from each half, staying very consistent. The construction is very good, I set my cigar down for one to two minutes at a time and it came right back to life. I never had to touch it up either, it kept a solid razor sharp burn all the way down to the nub.

Acme Route 66 Tandem Cigar Review

Right after the halfway mark I decide to try and cut off the cap of the cigar in hopes of opening it up a bit from the already pre-cut punch that I had been smoking through. I knew it was a bit risky as I had already smoked half the cigar and it was starting to get a tad warm around the cap, but I went for it anyway. And it was worth the risk! I instantly get a blast of smoke, and the draw feels almost like sucking through a straw… a huge difference from the pre-cut. With the added smoke, the flavors amp up a bit and I get more of that black pepper and sweetness, as well as earth coming through the finish.

Well into the final third, I know what to expect from the rest of the cigar. After all, I had just smoked one. Towards the end, it was what I thought, more subtle sweetness, hints of oak on the retrohale, black pepper and a strong earth, now dominating the finish right down to the nub.

Would I smoke this again?

Yes. I would cut it in half however, now that I know each half is the same. I also recommend anyone to cut the already punched caps, it really helps to open up the draw. Overall, it makes a very versatile mild-medium stick anyone could handle and enjoy. The construction is great as far as the burn goes, so you never have to worry about it going out, allowing you to just sit back and enjoy. I definitely recommend this to anyone interested in Acme’s new lineup, as well as new smokers who prefer a milder cigar that still has a few good flavors and subtle transitions.

Acme Route 66 Cigar Review and Rating

Acme Route 66
Acme did a great job of creating a unique vitola for one of their very first cigars. Although the flavors weren’t outstanding or complex, it did have a few notable transitions from half to half that made for a very consistent 2 hour stick. I really enjoyed the notes of cream and oak from the first few draws and wish I could have had more—it was nice to have that come back right at the halfway point to keep you interested in the rest of the cigar. Overall, the black pepper and subtle sweet tobacco core dominates the palate, with bitter earth coming in just at the end, but nothing too harsh. Acme definitely created an intriguing stick with the Route 66 Tandem, and it gives you a nice sense of pride in being an American, smoking this American-themed cigar. I will definitely be going back to try the rest of their lines.
  • Perfect burn (minus ash)
  • 2 hour stick (if smoked all the way through)
  • Good subtle transitions keeping each half consistent
  • Punch cut creates tight draw
  • Loose ash
Reader Rating: (2 Votes)
  • Aganorsa Leaf
  • Dunbarton Tobacco & Trust
  • Cigar Wars
Share This
Cigar ratings calculator icon

Download Our Advanced Cigar Ratings Calculator

Join our mailing list to receive Cigar Dojo's Advanced Cigar Ratings Calculator and begin ranking your cigar smoking experiences.

You have successfully subscribed! Please check your email to confirm your subscription. Instructions on how to download the Cigar Dojo Ratings Calculator will then be emailed to you.