Foundation Cigar Company proprietor Nick Melillo made his big debut into the premium cigar market in 2015, introducing the brand’s freshman release with the Nicaraguan-themed El Güegüense. The cigar may be one of the most difficult in the industry to pronounce… but Foundation had clearly struck a chord with craft enthusiasts—taking home multiple year-end cigar awards—including Cigar Dojo’s #3 Cigar of the Year.

Of course, this wasn’t actually Nick’s first foray into the world of premium cigars… not by a long shot. Here’s what we wrote on Nick’s backstory from our original review of the El Güegüense:

Nick entered the cigar industry in the ’90s, running a local brick & mortar in the New Haven, Connecticut area. Nick became well-acquainted with the newly-formed Drew Estate, selling the Drew Estate La Vieja Habana at the shop. Building a close relationship with Jonathan Drew over the years, Nick was offered the opportunity to be Jonathan’s right hand man in Nicaragua in 2003. He helped run the Drew Estate factory, setting standards for quality control and even began blending his own cigars in his spare time. Inspired from his roots in the Connecticut region, he began playing around with Connecticut Broadleaf—ultimately he crafted 10 blends to be tested by Steve Saka, the newly-appointed president of Drew Estate. These blends not only included the legendary Liga No. 9 blend, but UF-13, and JD4 as well. Nick’s portfolio eventually grew to include classic Drew Estate cigars such as Liga T52, L40, Dirty Rat, Feral Flying Pig, Nica Rustica, and one that holds special meaning to Cigar Dojo—Undercrown Dogma. Nick left Drew Estate in early 2014 to pursue his own projects, which have now been realized in the form of Foundation Cigar Company.

Understandably, when Nick debuted his own cigar project, he veered from his roots with Connecticut Broadleaf; not wanting to be pigeonholed into the dark and gritty maduros he had become known for with his time at Drew Estate. But now, a year later, Nick has given “maduro maniacs” what they’ve been waiting for with Foundation’s sophomore release: The Tabernacle.

*Images without Cigar Dojo watermark were provided by Foundation Cigar Company

The Tabernacle Corona Breakdown

  • Wrapper: Connecticut Broadleaf
  • Binder: Mexican San Andrés
  • Filler: Honduras (Jamastran Valley) | Nicaragua (Estelí & Jalapa Valley)
  • Factory: Tabacalera Fernandez S.A. (Nicaragua)
  • Production: Regular Production
  • Vitola: 5¼” × 46 Corona
  • Price: $9.00

The cigar’s name references the housing for the Ark of the Covenant, as described in the book of Exodus. The Tabernacle, a nomadic housing for the Ark, was eventually moved to King Solomon’s Temple in Jerusalem; estimated to be 300 years after its inception. The cigar’s packaging depicts Haile Selassie, the 225th King of Abyssinia—whose lineage traces directly to King Solomon and the Queen of Sheba (are you still with me?…).

The whole concept plays perfectly into brand owner Nick Melillo’s fascination with history and the Rastafari movement (another new project from Foundation focuses on Jamaican tobaccos and culture). Tying it all together, Haile Selassie, the man on the cigar’s box and bands, and former Emperor of Ethiopia, is regarded as a Jesus figure for the Rastafari Movement—which developed in Jamaica in the 1930s, following the coronation of Haile Selassie I as Emperor of Ethiopia.

The Tabernacle Blend

The Tabernacle takes on two backstories: one being the aforementioned tale of Biblical proportions – the other, as previously mentioned, the return of Nick Melillo, aka “The Chief of Broadleaf”, to the raw Connecticut Broadleaf maduro style he’s perfected over the past decade.

The wrapper, often regarded as cheap and ugly in the past, is now a favorite for fans of rich, earthy, and full-bodied maduro smoking experiences. But the leaf has long been a staple in Nick’s hometown of Connecticut.

I want to show my love for Connecticut Broadleaf. I was born in New Haven, where, at the turn of the century, there were many cigar factories.Nick Melillo

Nick partnered with industry veteran AJ Fernandez for The Tabernacle. The cigars are being rolled at AJ’s factory and Nick has reportedly been given full access to AJ’s finest tobaccos from his own farms in Nicaragua. The blend is finished with a special Connecticut Broadleaf wrapper, which was hand-selected over two years prior (before the introduction of Foundation) and fermented by AJ Fernandez and his meticulous standards.

Look / Feel

The Tabernacle features a similar look from Foundation’s last premium release (El Güegüense). The bands are primarily matte-finished, with highlights of gold foil woven into areas of the primarily black and white imagery of King Haile Selassie. The cigar’s wrapper is not “toothy”, as you may find on many Broadleaf cigars. Instead, it is dark, with a cloudy haze—like a lightly-dusted Chocolate Fudge Crinkle Cookie (look it up). This gives the texture a smooth and fuzzy, suede-like feel. The cigar is nicely rolled, having nearly invisible seams and a medium/firm bunch that gives it an overall solid feel in the hand. The Connecticut Broadleaf makes itself apparent with a bumpy/gnarled look—giving a slightly wavy shape from the head to foot.



The wrapper has light notes of cedar and something reminiscent of spent cap gun cartridges (nostalgia!); while the foot brings an aroma of hickory wood and an unexpected pork rinds note.

Smoking Experience

A small amount of toasting brings this 46 ring gauge Corona to life. The smoke is heavy off the get-go, bringing a punchy, black pepper spice in the retrohale and dessert-like chocolates and espresso on the palate. The draw is on the firmer side, but gives a medium smoke output—considering the more slender size, it feels appropriate and doesn’t require double puffs, etc. In fact, the flavors are at their best with smaller puffs; exhaling more through the mouth than the nostrils, as the retrohaled pepper tends to overpower otherwise. This style balances the smoke and also adds a nice, velvety texture.

Foundation Cigar Co. The Tabernacle cigar review

The cigar is just under “full” on flavor, with a medium-full strength and overall full body. As the flavors develop, there are notes of bitter, dark chocolate, fresh-cut wood, and a biting sensation that creeps down the back of your throat.

The burn is surprisingly fantastic, as this style often requires a good amount of age before the thick wrapper can burn properly. Ash holds in two-inch chunks, having a light and flakey, pastry structure and a wavy burn that needs no touch-ups. Further progression adds an appreciated sweetness to the mix. The smoke’s heavy mouthfeel is like syrup—both in texture, and sweet, maple flavor. It’s chewy, bringing dense notes of hickory wood, chocolate fudge, earth, and sweet syrup with a touch of cinnamon.

Foundation Cigar Co. The Tabernacle Corona cigar ash

Would I Smoke This Cigar Again?

Absolutely. This is the perfect late-night stick! It’s like the dessert smoke for those that don’t want a cloying gaudiness. In other words, your Dark Chocolate Chipotle Fudge, your Spicy Chocolate Bark, your Tabasco-Smoked Chipotle Dark Chocolate Ice Cream… that kind of dessert.

Foundation Cigar Co. The Tabernacle Corona cigar review and rating

The Tabernacle
Foundation Cigar Co. finally gives into consumer demand and offers a rich, Connecticut Broadleaf Maduro blend—on par with the world-famous cigars that proprietor Nick Melillo has become known for. The Tabernacle features an enticing backstory and a statistically solid blend, coupled with a refreshingly fair price tag that will attract “value smokers” and “luxury smokers” alike. The line showcases primarily thin vitolas that cater towards “craft junkies” and connoisseurs; and of the sizes smoked for review (Corona, Robusto, Toro), the Corona offered the biggest and most complex flavors. Altogether, a full and satisfying smoke that proves Melillo has much more to offer—even when playing with the familiar ingredients that won cigar enthusiasts over in the beginning.
Appearance94%
Burn/Construction92%
Draw85%
Flavor97%
Complexity89%
Price/Value92%
Pros
  • Dense flavors
  • No relights
  • Tastes luxurious for price point
Cons
  • Slightly firm draw
  • Spice in retro can dominate other flavors at cigar's start
92%Holy Maduro
Reader Rating: (16 Votes)
62%
  • William Burke

    The Corona is my favorite as well, in general and my favorite Tabernacle vitola.
    It’s not going to draw like a Liga Privada, but it seems like a close kin of those.

  • julius

    I cannot understand tight draw cigars. Might have to dry-boxing this stick.

    • Have you smoked The Tabernacle yet? I wouldn’t say the draw is “too tight”. It’s on the firmer side but isn’t anything to be worried about IMO.

      • julius

        I have not yet. But my primarily reason to read reviews before purchase is to check the construction conditions. Dojo’s review is always interesting and now I got to try this blend.

      • Gotchya, yeah I’d recommend a 5 or 10-pack buy to get started. Also, the larger sizes had much easier draws, although I still preferred the Corona.